Meeting Agenda: Evaluation of Cleaning Equipment for MuscatBay Lagoon
Date: 18.03.2024
Time: 10:00 am
Location: Muscat Bay Conference Room
Attendees: MB : Sapumal & Abdulrahim
Comprehensive and Enhanced Criteria Comparison:
Criterion/Model | 6000 HYDRO Euro6 C | D3 Tier 3 | 5000 Veloce Euro6 E |
Gross Vehicle Weight (Kg) | 12,500 | 7,500 (5,085 Kg net) | 12,160 |
Cleaning Performance (m²/h) | 32,000 | 90,000 | 105,000 |
Water Tank Capacity (L) | 5,900 | N/A (Opt. water system for dust suppression) | 400 |
Sweeping Width (mm) | Up to 3,200 (with extendable bar) | Up to 3,200 (with third brushes) | Up to 3,500 (with third brushes) |
Max Speed (Km/h) | 25 - 40 | 25 / 40 | 70 |
Emissions Compliance | Euro6 C | Tier 3 (EUnited 4 STAR for dust filtration) | Euro6 E |
Engine Power (kW) | 118 | 55.4 (KOHLER engine) | 152 (FPT IVECO engine) |
Fuel Consumption (l/h) | 8.2 | 5.5 | 8.4 |
Cleaning Methodology | - Water-based with high-pressure system | - Dry sweeping with optional water dust suppression | - Combination of sweeping and suction |
Waste Handling | - Direct to water stream for soluble wastes | - Solid waste collection in 3.3 m³ hopper, with dust control | - 5.3 m³ hopper for solid waste, high efficiency suction for dust |
Operational Features | - Adjustable front washing bar | - Advanced filter system for particulate matter reduction | - High-speed operation for time-efficient cleaning |
Environmental Adaptability | - Ideal for aquatic environments needing water cleaning | - Suitable for urban and industrial areas needing dust control | - Effective in a variety of environments, including urban areas |
Maintenance and Support | - Standardized parts for easy replacement | - Easy access to filters and brushes for maintenance | - Standardized components for straightforward servicing |
Technological Advancements | - Smart systems for water conservation | - Efficient dust filtration technology | - Advanced suction technology for waste removal |
Future-proofing Capabilities | - Upgradeable systems for emissions and efficiency | - Potential for technological upgrades in dust control | - Capabilities for upgrades to meet future environmental standards |
Mud Removal Capabilities | 5 - Excellent for muddy conditions, with a stainless steel washing bar and hydrostatic drive for control | 2 - May require additional methods for heavy mud, though water system assists in pre-wetting | 4 - Capable of mud removal with strong suction but may need pre-loosening |
Mechanical Sweeping System | Yes, includes a mechanical system for debris pick-up | Yes, effective mechanical brushing | Yes, mechanical system present |
Vacuum Sweeping System | Yes, supports dust control and loose debris suction | Yes, with a high airflow suction system | Yes, dual suction for enhanced collection |
High-Efficiency Filter | Yes, supports superior dust control and filtration | Yes, high-performance filter system | Yes, high-efficiency GORE filtration system |
Water Usage Efficiency | High, water-saving design, can operate with or without water | Moderate, water is sparingly used for dust suppression, can work dry | Moderate, equipped with a water system but detailed efficiency not specified |
Productivity | High, with large working widths and fast brush speeds | High, fast brush speeds and large working widths contribute to superior productivity | High, fast operational speed for large area coverage |
Technology Integration | Advanced, featuring Technology 4.0 with CAN Bus system | Advanced, Technology 4.0 for optimized performance and operation | Advanced, includes modern operational technologies |
Compliance | Yes, meets Euro 6 C emission standards with three-stage engine filtration | Yes, meets Euro 6 standards and includes three-stage engine filtration | Yes, complies with Euro 6 E standards but specifics need clarification |
Suitability for MuscatBay Lagoon | Highly suitable, especially for water pollution control and heavy mud conditions | Suitable for solid waste and light to moderate mud conditions | Suitable for general cleaning and maintenance but may need additional measures for heavy mud removal |
Meeting Summary and Action Plan for MuscatBay Lagoon Cleaning Equipment
Outcome of Discussion:
- The 6000 HYDRO Euro6 C was preemptively selected based on its specifications and suitability for MuscatBay Lagoon. The supplier's site evaluation supported this decision, affirming the model's appropriateness for the lagoon's challenging conditions.
- Maintenance services are assured through the supplier's workshop, which will handle routine servicing and any necessary repairs.
- The supplier has offered a one-year warranty covering manufacturing defects for the 6000 HYDRO Euro6 C.
- Additional required accessories, such as a heavy-duty rubber blade for pushing mud and a high-pressure jet for cleaning, have been discussed. These will be outfitted to enhance the machine's mud removal capabilities in line with the unique demands of the site.
- The supplier was unable to provide a concrete price but estimated the cost to be between 80,000 to 100,000 Omani Rials.
- A direct demonstration of the 6000 HYDRO Euro6 C at MuscatBay Lagoon was unavailable. However, it was noted that Muscat Municipality uses a similar, albeit older, model.
Next Steps:
Coordination with Muscat Municipality: The supplier/Muscat Bay to witness the operational performance of the Municipality's sweeper to assess functionality and effectiveness in conditions akin to those at MuscatBay Lagoon.
Accessory Fitting and Customisation: Engage with the supplier to ensure the 6000 HYDRO Euro6 C is equipped with the agreed-upon accessories, ensuring it is tailored to the specific mud removal needs at the lagoon.
Warranty and Service Agreements: Clarify the terms of the warranty, particularly in relation to the additional accessories and their installation, and confirm the extent of support and service available post-purchase.
‣
Meeting Points Discussed
Introduction
- Briefly introduce the purpose of the meeting.
- Provide an overview of the MuscatBay Lagoon's unique cleaning requirements.
Discussion Points
- Emissions Compliance: Compare the Euro6 C (6000 HYDRO), Tier 3 (D3 Tier 3), and Euro6 E (5000 Veloce) standards. How do these standards align with our environmental objectives?
- Water Efficiency: Discuss the water tank capacity and conservation technology of each model. How does the high-pressure system in the 6000 HYDRO model contribute to water efficiency?
- Dust Control: Evaluate the dust control capabilities of each vehicle. How effective is the advanced filter system in the D3 Tier 3 model?
2. Operational Needs
- Discuss the cleaning performance metrics (m²/h) of each model and their suitability for the Lagoon's size and type of debris.
- Compare the sweeping widths and how they impact cleaning efficiency.
- Evaluate the operational features, such as hydrostatic transmission and adjustable front washing bars, for each model.
3. Maintenance and Support
- Inquire about local service support, availability of maintenance services, and parts in the region.
- Discuss the ease of access for routine maintenance tasks for each model.
4. Cost of Ownership
- Review the initial purchase costs and compare them with the expected operating and maintenance costs.
- Discuss warranty options and any included service agreements.
5. Future Upgrades
- Explore the potential for future upgrades on emissions, efficiency, and cleaning capabilities.
- Discuss how each model can be adapted to evolving cleaning needs and environmental regulations.
Evaluation Criteria
- Compatibility with Operational Needs: Does the model meet the specific cleaning requirements of the MuscatBay Lagoon?
- Environmental Impact: Is the model aligned with our sustainability goals?
- Cost-Effectiveness: Consider both the initial cost and the long-term value.
- Vendor Support: Evaluate the level of after-sales support and maintenance services available.
Decision-Making Process
- Outline the next steps in the decision-making process, including any further information required from the supplier.
- Discuss timelines for purchasing and implementation.
Closing
- Summarize key points and conclusions from the meeting.
- Thank all participants for their time and contributions.
Follow-Up Actions
Coordination with Muscat Municipality.
Accessory Fitting and Customisation.
Warranty and Service Agreements