← Back

New NEDC Electrical CT Meters Installation for all Buildings at Z01 Project

1. Overview of Proposals:

• Company: THILAL ALKATHEEB TRADING & CONTRACTING L.L.C.
• Scope: Comprehensive service connection works.
• Total Cost: R.O. 16,395.75 (inclusive of VAT)
• Company: AL MAJADEEF TRADING LLC
• Scope: Focus on CT meter installations.
• Total Cost: R.O. 14,673.75 (inclusive of VAT)

2. Visual Comparison:

Company	Scope of Work	Total Cost
THILAL ALKATHEEB TRADING	Comprehensive service connection works	16,395 R.O.
AL MAJADEEF TRADING LLC	Focus on CT meter installations	14,673 R.O.

3. Key Considerations:

• Both companies propose to work as per NEDC standards.
• The quotes from both are valid for 30 days.
• Completion is contingent upon receiving the Muscat municipality NOC for individual meters.
• Both proposals exclude NEDC Payments, such as meter disconnection, reconnection, and deposit charges.

4. Additional Information:

• Quality of Materials: Specific details about the quality of materials are not explicitly mentioned in the proposals.
• Team Qualifications: The first proposal mentions an individual named "SENTHIL KUMAR" with the title "ELECTRICAL ENGINEER". Detailed qualifications or experience of the team are not provided.
• Proposed Timeline: Completion is based on receiving the Muscat municipality NOC for individual meters.
• Terms and Conditions: Both proposals specify terms related to NEDC standards, quote validity, and exclusions.

Recommendation: Up to those proposals only, since the scope almost same with only the differences in the cost of both proposals, I recommend further discussions with both vendors to negotiate terms provide us with the following additional information:

1. Details about the quality of materials that will be used.
2. Information about the experience and qualifications of your team.
3. The proposed timeline for the project.
4. The terms and conditions of your contract.

Please let me know if you require any further details or if there are any recommendations from your side on this subject.

Warm regards,

Assets & Operation Manager

Muscat Bay

The comparison using the company name:

The information from the proposals of the company names are as follows:

• Option One: THILAL ALKATHEEB TRADING & CONTRACTING L.L.C.
• Option Two: AL MAJADEEF TRADING LLC

Comparison between THILAL ALKATHEEB TRADING & AL MAJADEEF TRADING LLC

1. Scope of Work:
• THILAL ALKATHEEB TRADING & CONTRACTING L.L.C.: The proposal covers service connection works for Muscat Bay. This includes various installations and modifications across different areas.
• AL MAJADEEF TRADING LLC: The proposal focuses on the supply and installation of CT meters for different buildings, along with associated works.
2. Total Cost:
• THILAL ALKATHEEB TRADING & CONTRACTING L.L.C.: The grand total quoted is R.O. 16,395.75, inclusive of a 5% VAT.
• AL MAJADEEF TRADING LLC: The grand total quoted is R.O. 14,673.75, inclusive of a 5% VAT.
3. Terms and Conditions:
• THILAL ALKATHEEB TRADING & CONTRACTING L.L.C.: The terms specify that all works will be executed as per NEDC standard. The quote is valid for 30 days and is subject to reconfirmation after that period. The completion is contingent upon receiving the Muscat municipality NOC for individual meters. The proposal excludes all NEDC Payments, including meter disconnection, reconnection, and meter deposit charges.
• AL MAJADEEF TRADING LLC: The terms specify that the work will be executed as per the NEDC standard. The quote is valid for 30 days, and the completion is based on receiving the Muscat municipality NOC for individual meters. The proposal excludes all NEDC Payments, including meter disconnection, reconnection, and meter deposit charges.
4. Completion Time:
• THILAL ALKATHEEB TRADING & CONTRACTING L.L.C.: The completion is based on receiving the Muscat municipality NOC for individual meters.
• AL MAJADEEF TRADING LLC: The completion is based on receiving the Muscat municipality NOC for individual meters.
5. Exclusions:
• THILAL ALKATHEEB TRADING & CONTRACTING L.L.C.: All NEDC Payments, including meter disconnection, reconnection, and meter deposit charges, are excluded from the proposal.
• AL MAJADEEF TRADING LLC: All NEDC Payments, including meter disconnection, reconnection, and meter deposit charges, are excluded from the proposal.

Electrical Segregation Meters of Muscat Bay Z01 Project

Tasks - Scope of Work for CT Meter Installation Project

• New NEDC Electrical CT Meters Installation for all Buildings at Z01 Project
• Proposals received
• The comparison using the company name:
• Tasks - Scope of Work for CT Meter Installation Project